State Taxes And Student Loan Forgiveness

You may have heard the news - student loan forgiveness of any type is now tax free! And you might have always known that some programs like Public Service Loan Forgiveness were tax free, at least federally. But did you know that every state has a different law regarding state taxes on loan forgiveness?

The American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 added an exclusion from income on federal income tax returns for student loan forgiveness through December 31, 2025. 

But what about state policies for taxing student loan forgiveness? Some states provide tax-free status for student loan forgiveness and some do not. This could be an unexpected tax bomb waiting for some Americans.

Overview

While student loan forgiveness is tax-free federally through December 31, 2025, it may not be tax-free on the state-level. In fact, prior to the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021, some student loan forgiveness programs were taxable on the federal level. See this guide to Federal taxes and student loan forgiveness.

Based on our research of state tax laws, you may still have to pay a "tax bomb" on student loan forgiveness to your state. In some states, the discharge of debt is considered taxable income. For example, if you have $10,000 in student loans forgiven, that amount gets added to your income, and you pay tax on the result.

Currently, we see the following:

• 11 states with no state income tax, so loan forgiveness is tax-free
• 20 states that automatically conform with federal tax rules, so loan forgiveness is tax-free

That leaves 19 states, where student loan forgiveness may or may not be tax free. Specifically, there may some types and/or timing of loan forgiveness that may be tax free, while other forms and/or timing are not. 

For example, Virginia excludes the total and permanent disability discharge from income on state income tax returns, but only for veterans, and only through 2025.

As such, state taxes and loan forgiveness add a messy complication to student loan borrowers.

Find your state below and see what laws your state follows.

States With No Income Tax

Nine states provide tax-free status for student loan forgiveness because they do not have a personal income tax. These states include:

• Alaska
• Florida
• Nevada
• New Hampshire
• South Dakota
• Tennessee
• Texas
• Washington
• Wyoming

New Hampshire and Tennessee have a tax on interest and dividends, but not other income. Also, the Tennessee tax on interest and dividends is ending in 2021.

Related: Ultimate Guide To State Income Taxes

States That Automatically Conform With Federal Tax Rules

There are 20 states that base their definition of income on the federal definition of adjusted gross income (AGI) from the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, and automatically update their definition with changes in federal law.

Accordingly, changes in federal tax law, such as the new exclusion from income for student loan forgiveness, will automatically affect state income tax in these states. These states include: 

• Connecticut
• Delaware
• Illinois
• Iowa
• Kansas
• Louisiana
• Maryland
• Massachusetts
• Michigan
• Missouri
• Montana
• Nebraska
• New Mexico
• New York
• Ohio
• Oklahoma
• Rhode Island
• Utah
• Vermont
• Washington, D.C.

Massachusetts and Michigan use a hybrid approach, with taxpayers being able to choose to use the federal AGI. In addition, Iowa has a subtraction for military student loan repayment.

New York does not consider distributions from 529 plans to repay student loans to be qualified. New York has an explicit subtraction for student loan death and disability discharges.

Three states base their definition of income on the federal definition of taxable income instead of AGI and automatically update their definition with changes in federal law. These states are Colorado, North Dakota and Oregon.

States That Conform With Federal Tax Rules As Of A Specific Date

There are several states that must pass laws to incorporate changes in the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 (IRC). Not all will.

Even when they do, the state laws may lag changes in federal law by a year or more. One must compare the date of the version of the IRC upon which the state tax law is based with the date upon which the tax-free status was enacted for various student loan forgiveness and discharges.

In effect, these states have decoupled their definition of income from the federal definition of income. Accordingly, these states do not automatically include the exclusion from income for student loan forgiveness from the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021.

Student loan forgiveness may be taxable in these states, depending on the date you receive student loan forgiveness and when the state changes the law.

States That Conform With The Federal Definition Of "AGI" As Of A Specific Date

There are 11 states that base their definition of income on the federal definition of adjusted gross income (AGI) as of a specific date. These states are:

• Arizona
• California
• Georgia
• Hawaii
• Indiana
• Kentucky
• Maine
• North Carolina
• Virginia
• West Virginia
• Wisconsin

California provides tax-free status for the borrower defense to repayment and closed school discharges through December 1, 2024. California also provides tax-free status for death and disability discharges through January 1, 2026. Public service loan forgiveness is tax-free in California. 

Maine provides a state income tax credit, the Opportunity Maine Tax Credit, to reimburse student loan payments for recent college graduates who live and work in Maine. Maine also provides a subtraction for student loan payments made by the borrower’s employer under the Maine Educational Opportunity Program (FAQ). 

Employer student loan repayment assistance programs (LRAPs) are taxable in North Carolina in 2020.

Virginia excludes the total and permanent disability discharge from income on state income tax returns, but only for veterans and only through 2025. Virginia provides a subtraction from income for student loan discharges due to the student’s death. It does not apply to discharges of private student loans. This may have been superseded by changes to federal tax law.

Arizona, Virginia and Wisconsin do not have an addition to income for student loan forgiveness and other student loan discharges.

States That Conform With The Federal Definition Of "Taxable Income" As Of A Specific Date

Three states base their definition of income on the federal definition of taxable income instead of AGI as of a specific date. These states are Idaho, Minnesota and South Carolina.

Minnesota generally conforms with federal law concerning the taxation of student loan forgiveness. Minnesota has a subtraction for the forgiveness after 20 or 25 years in an income-driven repayment plan and for Minnesota Teacher Shortage Loan Forgiveness. Minnesota provides a nonrefundable student loan credit for payments made on qualified student loans. 

This table shows the effective date of changes to the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 or Higher Education Act of 1965 to exclude certain types of student loan forgiveness from income. Comparing the date of the version of the IRC to which the state conforms with these dates may provide an indication as to whether each type of loan forgiveness is tax-free.

States That Do Not Base Income On Federal Tax Rules

Five states base their definition of income on their own definition of gross income. These states do not conform with the federal definition of income. Any changes in the federal definition of income will not affect these states.

The exclusion from income for student loan forgiveness from the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 does not apply to these states. These states must pass laws to exclude student loan forgiveness from income. Accordingly, student loan forgiveness may be taxable in these states.

These states are:

• Alabama
• Arkansas
• Mississippi
• New Jersey
• Pennsylvania

Arkansas has a subtraction for interest paid on qualified education loans. New Jersey has an exclusion from income for the cancellation of debt.

Pennsylvania taxes forgiveness of student loan debt for work in specific occupations. Thus, public service loan forgiveness and teacher loan forgiveness is taxable in Pennsylvania. Employer-paid student loan repayment programs (LRAPs) are taxable in Pennsylvania. The discharge of indebtedness is taxable in Pennsylvania unless it is specifically excluded from taxable income.

Disclaimer

This article was based on a review of state income tax forms and state law.

No claims are made about the accuracy, timeliness or usefulness of the information provided in this article. The information described in this article may change. 

This article does not provide legal, financial or tax advice. This information is general in nature and may not apply to the specific circumstances of individual readers.

Readers should seek specific guidance directly from a qualified accountant or tax professional in their state. This article is not and is not intended to be used as a substitute for professional advice.