• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The College Investor

Student Loans, Investing, Building Wealth

  • About
  • Podcast
  • Research
  • Contact
  • Save For College
      • How To Start

      • How To Save For College
      • How To Pay For College
      • What Is the Average Cost of College?
      • What Is A 529 Plan and Where to Open One in Your State
      • How Much Should You Have In A 529 Plan By Age
      • How To Use A 529 Plan For Private Elementary And High School
      • What Are Qualified Expenses For A 529 Plan (And What Doesn’t Count)?
      • The Best Brokers To Open A 529 Plan
      • Tools + Accounts

      • 529 Plans: The Ultimate College Savings Plan
      • 529 Plan Contribution Limits
      • Prepaid Tuition Plans | What To Know
      • Understanding And Using 529A ABLE Accounts
      • Using A Roth IRA To Save And Pay For College
      • FAFSA Deadlines for Financial Aid
      • CollegeBacker Review
      • Upromise Review
      • UNest Review
      • Other Options

      • Student Loan And Financial Aid Programs By State
      • The Guide To Military And VA Education Benefits
      • How To Fill Out The FAFSA
      • How To Find College Scholarships
      • The Best College Scholarship Search Websites
      • How To Find Grants To Pay For College
      • Pell Grants: What They Are And How To Qualify
      • Understanding Federal Work-Study
      • How To Use A 529 Plan If Your Child Doesn’t Go To College
  • Student Loans
      • Borrowing

        • How Student Loans Work
        • How To Apply For A Student Loan
        • Best Student Loans And Rates In January 2023
        • 10 Best Private Student Loans Of January 2023
        • Best Student Loans To Pay For Graduate School
        • Best Student Loans To Pay For Medical School
        • Parent Loans To Pay For College
        • No-Cosigner Student Loan Options
        • Guide To Income Sharing Agreements (ISAs)
        • Best International Student Loans
      • Get Out Of Debt

        • Best Student Loan Refinance Companies In January 2023
        • Best Student Loan Repayment Plans
        • Best Student Loan Refinancing Bonuses And Promotional Offers Of January 2023
        • Student Loan Forgiveness Programs (The Complete List)
        • The Full List Of Student Loan Forgiveness Programs By State
        • Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF)
        • Top Student Loan Scams
        • Average Student Loan Monthly Payment
        • Average Student Loan Debt By Year
      • Reviews

        • Credible Review
        • Splash Review
        • Ascent Review
        • Citizens Bank Review
        • Commonbond Review
        • Earnest Review
        • ELFI Review
        • Laurel Road Review
        • LendKey Review
        • SoFi Review
  • Investing
      • How To Start

        • How To Start Investing in High School
        • How To Start Investing In College
        • How To Start Investing In Your Twenties For 22 – 29 Year Olds
        • How To Start Investing In Your 30s For 30 – 39 Year Olds
        • How To Start Investing With $100 Or Less
        • How To Give Kids The Gift Of Stock
        • What Is Dividend Growth Investing
        • IRA Rollover Chart
      • Tools + Accounts

        • Best Online Stock Brokers
        • The Best Traditional And Roth IRA Accounts
        • The Best Robo-Advisors
        • The Best Investing Apps
        • The Best Places to Trade Options
        • The Best Places To Open A Health Savings Account
        • The Best Solo 401k Providers
        • The Best Self-Directed IRA Providers Of 2023
        • Best Cryptocurrency Exchanges
      • Reviews

        • Vanguard Review
        • Fidelity Review 2023
        • M1 Finance Review
        • TD Ameritrade Review 2023
        • Charles Schwab Review
        • Robinhood Review
        • Webull Review
        • Betterment Review 2023
        • Wealthfront Review
  • Earn More Money
      • Extra Income

        • 20 Best Side Hustles You Can Start Earning With In 2023
        • 53 Side Hustle Ideas To Make Money Fast
        • 100 Ways To Make Money In College
        • 80 Ways To Make Money From Home In 2023
        • 5 Quick Money Making Ideas (That Take Less Than 1 Hour)
        • 10 Interesting Ways You Can Make Money Driving
        • High-Paying Side Gigs That Earn $1,000 or More Per Month
        • The 10 Best Money-Making Apps
        • Paid Surveys: Earn Money For Giving Your Opinion Online
        • 10 Crazy Ways To Make $10,000 You’ve Never Heard Of
      • Build Wealth

        • 40 Passive Income Ideas You Can Use To Build Wealth In 2023
        • 3 Ways To Make $50,000 Per Year Without Working With Passive Income
        • How To Become A Real Estate Investor With Just $500
        • 15 Best Online Business Ideas
        • Residual Income: 7 Super Smart Ways to Build It
        • The Most Common Multiple Income Streams
        • How To Become A Real Estate Mogul With Only $10,000
      • Reviews

        • Fundrise Review
        • RealtyMogul Review
        • FarmTogether Review
        • AcreTrader Review
        • Swagbucks Review
        • Survey Junkie Review
        • TopCashback Review
        • DoorDash Review
  • Personal Finance
      • Banking

        • 10 Best High Yield Savings Accounts Of January 2023
        • 10 Best Money Market Accounts Of January 2023
        • 10 Best Free Checking Accounts In January 2023
        • Best Bank CD Rates Of January 2023
        • 10 Best Business Checking Accounts In January 2023
        • Best Online Banks Of January 2023
        • Best Credit Unions Nationwide Of January 2023
        • Best College Student Checking Accounts Of January 2023
      • Insurance

        • Best Life Insurance Companies
        • Renters Insurance
        • Car Insurance
        • Pet Insurance
        • Umbrella Insurance
        • Disability Insurance
        • Tuition Insurance
        • Travel Insurance
      • Credit Tools

        • Best Budgeting Apps
        • Cash Advance Apps
        • How To Get A Free Credit Score Report
        • Best Credit Monitoring Services For 2023
        • Debt Settlement: Inside The Secret World
        • Credit Repair Explained: Should You Pay For Help?
        • Best Personal Loan Companies And Lenders
        • Online Loan Companies To Borrow From Home
      • Tax

        • Best Tax Software
        • Free Tax Software
        • IRS Tax Refund Calendar
        • Common IRS Questions and Errors
        • Federal Tax Brackets
        • Capital Gains Tax Brackets
        • 401k Contribution Limits
        • IRA Contribution Limits
        • HSA Contribution Limits
  • Forum
  • Search
Home » Student Loans » Federal » How To Potentially Implement Broad Student Loan Forgiveness

How To Potentially Implement Broad Student Loan Forgiveness

Updated: July 21, 2022 By Mark Kantrowitz

Tweet
Share
Share
Pin
Email
Print

At The College Investor, we want to help you navigate your finances. To do this, many or all of the products featured here may be from our partners. This doesn’t influence our evaluations or reviews. Our opinions are our own. Any investing information provided on this page is for educational purposes only. The College Investor does not offer investment advisor or brokerage services, nor does it recommend buying or selling particular stocks, securities, or other investments. Learn more here.Advertiser Disclosure

There are thousands of financial products and services out there, and we believe in helping you understand which is best for you, how it works, and will it actually help you achieve your financial goals. We're proud of our content and guidance, and the information we provide is objective, independent, and free.

But we do have to make money to pay our team and keep this website running! Our partners compensate us. TheCollegeInvestor.com has an advertising relationship with some or all of the offers included on this page, which may impact how, where, and in what order products and services may appear. The College Investor does not include all companies or offers available in the marketplace. And our partners can never pay us to guarantee favorable reviews (or even pay for a review of their product to begin with).

For more information and a complete list of our advertising partners, please check out our full Advertising Disclosure. TheCollegeInvestor.com strives to keep its information accurate and up to date. The information in our reviews could be different from what you find when visiting a financial institution, service provider or a specific product's website. All products and services are presented without warranty.

How To Implement Broad Student Loan Forgiveness

Although the President does not have the legal authority to forgive all federal student loans with the stroke of a pen, there may be a way for the U.S. Secretary of Education to legally implement broad student loan forgiveness through a regulatory change. 

Remember, the four income-driven repayment plans are also student loan forgiveness programs. The income-driven repayment plans forgive the remaining debt after a number of years in repayment. 

One of the income-driven repayment plans, the Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR) plan, provides the U.S. Department of Education with broad regulatory authority. Congress specifically authorized several key potential changes in ICR. 

This regulatory authority is so broad that the U.S. Department of Education could use the rulemaking process to issue new regulations that transform ICR into a new student loan forgiveness program.

This version of broad student loan forgiveness would be limited to federal loans in the Direct Loan program that had been in repayment for at least 5 years (maybe at least 10 years). It would also have to be means-tested, due to the nature of income-driven repayment plans.

Table of Contents
What Is Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR)?
Regulatory Authority To Modify Income-Contingent Repayment
How To Create A New Loan Forgiveness Program
Will It Survive Legal Challenge?

What Is Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR)?

Income-Contingent Repayment, or ICR, was the first income-driven repayment plan. It became available in 1994-95 in the Direct Loan program. Other income-driven repayment plans were added in 2009 (IBR), 2012 (PAYE) and 2015 (REPAYE).

Income-driven repayment plans base the monthly loan payment on a percentage of discretionary income.

With ICR, the monthly loan payment is 20% of discretionary income, where discretionary income is defined as the amount by which adjusted gross income (AGI) exceeds 100% of the poverty line. 

ICR forgives the remaining debt after 25 years’ worth of payments, a total of 300 payments.

Regulatory Authority To Modify Income-Contingent Repayment

The four income-driven repayment plans are, in effect, student loan forgiveness programs because they forgive the remaining debt after a specified number of payments. 

The U.S. Department of Education has the legal authority to modify the Income-Contingent Repayment plan into a new repayment plan with more lenient requirements for student loan forgiveness, as it has already done twice before.

The statutory language defining Income-Contingent Repayment provides the U.S. Department of Education with broad regulatory authority to modify the details of the program.

In particular:

  • The U.S. Department of Education can specify the repayment term required by the repayment plan. The repayment term must be an “extended period of time not to exceed 25 years” but can be shorter than 25 years. [20 USC 1087e(d)(1)(D)]
  • The U.S. Department of Education can specify procedures for determining the borrower’s repayment obligation based on the appropriate portion of annual income. [20 USC 1087e(e)(1), (2) and (4)]
  • The U.S. Department of Education can specify procedures for alternate documentation of income. [20 USC 1087e(e)(3)]
  • The U.S. Department of Education can specify limitations on the capitalization of interest. [20 USC 1087e(e)(5)]
  • The U.S. Department of Education can make adjustments to the borrower’s loan payments based on special circumstances, such as loss of employment. [20 USC 1087e(e)(6)]
  • The U.S. Department of Education may obtain certain information from federal tax returns from the IRS to determine eligibility for and repayment obligations under an income-contingent repayment plan with the approval of the borrower. [26 USC 6103(l)(13)] The information includes tax filing status, adjusted gross income, and number of exemptions, as well as verification of non-filing status.

This regulatory authority is broad enough that the U.S. Department of Education was able to use it to implement the Pay-As-You-Earn Repayment (PAYE) and Revised Pay-As-You-Earn Repayment (REPAYE) repayment plans at 34 CFR 685.209(a) and (c), respectively.

These regulations included a smaller definition of discretionary income, a smaller percentage of discretionary income, a shorter repayment terms and various requirements for forgiveness of the remaining loan balance. These changes involve all of the dimensions required to implement a new student loan forgiveness program.

How To Create A New Loan Forgiveness Program

The U.S. Department of Education can use this regulatory authority to issue new regulations that modify Income-Contingent Repayment into a new student loan forgiveness program, as follows.

  • The repayment term can be shorter than 25 years. Congress did not define what it meant by an “extended period of time.” However, the repayment term cannot be less than 5 years, per 20 USC 1078(b)(9)(A), unless the borrower specifically requests a shorter period, which would necessitate an application process. The shortest repayment term for an extended repayment plan is 10 years. Public service loan forgiveness requires 120 qualifying payments (10 years’ worth of payments), so it would be odd for an income-driven repayment plan to require less than 10 years. Otherwise, the U.S. Department of Education can define “extended period of time” in the regulations as it sees fit. For example, the U.S. Department of Education could choose to implement a new income-driven repayment plan that forgives the remaining debt after 12 or 15 years of payments, if it so wished. But at a minimum, it could create a loan forgiveness program with as little as 5 years of repayment.
  • When determining whether the end of the repayment term has been reached, the U.S. Department of Education must count all time periods during which the borrower was in an economic hardship deferment, a standard repayment plan or a reduced payment under an income-driven repayment plan, or making payments of at least the standard repayment amount under other repayment plans, except for periods when the borrower was in default on their loans. This includes time periods during which the borrower made payments on loans in the Federal Family Education Loan Program (FFELP) and Federal Perkins Loan Program, not just the Direct Loan Program. [20 USC 1087e(e)(6)]. Due to the CARES Act, the suspended payments during the payment pause and interest waiver do count as payments on an income-driven repayment plan.
  • The repayment obligation must be based on a portion of the borrower’s income. This portion can be zero, as is currently the case for borrowers with income under 100% or 150% of the poverty line in the current income-driven repayment plans. The U.S. Department of Education could provide full forgiveness of the remaining debt to low-income borrowers whose income falls below a specific dollar threshold (e.g., $50,000), a specific multiple of the poverty line (e.g., 250% of the poverty line) or a specific multiple of the borrower’s student loan balance, or through a similar change in the definition of discretionary income.
  • Although the repayment obligation must be based on a portion of the borrower’s annual income, this does not prevent the consideration of several years’ worth of income.
  • If the U.S. Department of Education bases the repayment obligation on a percentage of discretionary income, they could choose high enough of a percentage of discretionary income to prevent wealthy borrowers from qualifying for full student loan forgiveness. For example, if the annual loan payments were based on 20% of the amount by which income exceeds $50,000, over five years the total payments would equal the amount by which income exceeds $50,000. Someone earning $100,000 would have to pay at least $50,000 toward their student loans.
  • Because the borrower’s approval is required for the U.S. Department of Education to obtain information from the IRS, obtaining financial information from the IRS to implement loan forgiveness might require an application process, preventing automatic implementation. But, given the strong financial incentive of loan forgiveness, this should not be a significant problem.
  • Nothing prevents the U.S. Department of Education from establishing a deadline by which the borrower must apply for the student loan forgiveness.

Although loan forgiveness programs based on Income-Contingent Repayment are limited to loans in the Direct Loan program, borrowers could consolidate FFELP loans and Federal Perkins Loans into a Federal Direct Consolidation Loan to qualify (similar to the Biden Waiver in effect now for PSLF). Parent PLUS loans are not directly eligible, per 20 USC 1087e(d)(1)(D), but a Federal Direct Consolidation Loan that repaid a Parent PLUS loan would qualify.

The new regulations could be implemented either through the traditional notice-and-comment rulemaking process, or as an interim final rule.

Will It Survive Legal Challenge?

Proposals for broad student loan forgiveness are likely to face legal challenge. But, student loan forgiveness that is implemented by issuing new regulations is more likely to survive legal challenge than student loan forgiveness implemented through executive order.

The Congressional Review Act of 1996 (P.L. 104-121) allows Congress to overturn new federal regulations in their entirety by passing a joint resolution within 60 legislative days after publication of the new rule. Passing the joint resolution requires a simple majority vote of the House and Senate, but can be vetoed by the President, in which case a two-thirds supermajority will be required to overturn the veto.

The joint resolution is generally not subject to filibuster. This is in contrast to regular legislation to modify or block all or part of a new regulation, which is subject to filibuster and does not benefit from expedited consideration.

The 60-day period resets if Congress adjourns in the middle of the 60-day period. Since 60 legislative days generally spans 4-5 months, this allows a new session of Congress to overturn regulations issued during the last several months of the previous session of Congress.

Congress is unlikely to overturn regulations when there is split control of Congress or when Congress is controlled by the same party as the President.

If Congress does not use the Congressional Review Act to overturn a new regulation, it significantly weakens the argument that the new regulations are contrary to the intent of Congress. After all, Congress had the opportunity to overturn the new regulations through the Congressional Review Act, but did not do so. This is in contrast with executive orders, which cannot be overturned through the Congressional Review Act.

Regulations can also be challenged by bringing a lawsuit under the Administrative Procedures Act (P.L. 79-404), if the court finds that the regulation is "arbitrary and capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with the law” [5 USC 706(2)(A)]. If a regulation is the result of reasoned consideration of the facts and law, as well as adequate consideration of the consequences of and potential alternatives to the proposed rule, it is likely to survive such a challenge. The judicial system provides a lot of deference to regulations established by the executive branch, provided that the executive branch follows proper procedure.

Mark Kantrowitz
Mark Kantrowitz

Mark Kantrowitz is an expert on student financial aid, scholarships, 529 plans, and student loans. He has been quoted in more than 10,000 newspaper and magazine articles about college admissions and financial aid. Mark has written for the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, Reuters, U.S. News & World Report, MarketWatch, Money Magazine, Forbes, Newsweek, and Time. You can find his work on Student Aid Policy here.

Mark is the author of five bestselling books about scholarships and financial aid and holds seven patents. Mark serves on the editorial board of the Journal of Student Financial Aid, the editorial advisory board of Bottom Line/Personal, and is a member of the board of trustees of the Center for Excellence in Education. He previously served as a member of the board of directors of the National Scholarship Providers Association. Mark has two Bachelor’s degrees in mathematics and philosophy from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and a Master’s degree in computer science from Carnegie Mellon University (CMU).

How To Potentially Implement Broad Student Loan Forgiveness

Editor: Robert Farrington

Editorial Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here are author’s alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, airlines or hotel chain, or other advertiser and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.
Comment Policy: We invite readers to respond with questions or comments. Comments may be held for moderation and are subject to approval. Comments are solely the opinions of their authors'. The responses in the comments below are not provided or commissioned by any advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any company. It is not anyone's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.
Subscribe
Connect with
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
Notify of

I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Primary Sidebar

Student Loan Resources

Featured Lender Reviews

>  Credible (recommended)
>  Splash (recommended)
>  ELFI
>  LendKey
>  Earnest
>  Laurel Road

Paying For College

  • Best Student Loans And Rates
  • Best Private Student Loans
  • Student Loan And Financial Aid Programs By State
  • Student Loans For Community College
  • Best International Student Loans
  • Best Student Loans For Graduate School
  • Best Student Loans For Your MBA
  • Best Student Loans For Medical School
  • How To Get A Private Student Loan With No Cosigner
  • How To Get A Student Loan With Bad Credit

Navigating Repayment

  • How To Select The Best Student Loan Repayment Plan
  • 5 Legal Ways To Lower Your Student Loan Payment
  • How To Use A 529 Plan For Student Loan Repayment
  • These Companies Offer Student Loan Repayment Assistance

Student Loan Forgiveness

  • Student Loan Forgiveness Programs (The Complete List)
  • Student Loan Forgiveness Programs By State
  • President Biden’s Student Loan Forgiveness Plan
  • Public Service Loan Forgiveness
  • Borrower Defense To Repayment
  • For-Profit College Student Loan Forgiveness List
  • Private Student Loan Forgiveness
  • Trade School Loan Forgiveness Programs

Student Loan Refinance

  • Best Student Loan Refinance Companies
  • Best Student Loan Refinancing Bonuses And Promotional Offers
  • Lenders That Offer Student Loan Refinancing Without A Degree
  • How To Refinance An International Student Loan
  • Best Medical School Student Loan Refinancing

More On Student Loans

  • Top Student Loan Scams
  • Does The Government Profit Off Of Student Loans?
  • Statue Of Limitations Laws For Student Loans
  • What Should You Do With Your Old FFELP Loans?
  • How To Get A Refund Of Your Federal Student Loan Payments

Footer

Who We Are

The College Investor is an independent, advertising-supported financial media publisher, focusing on news, product reviews, and comparisons.

Connect

  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Press & Media

About

  • About
  • Our Team
  • Podcast
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • How We Make Money
  • Archives

Social

Copyright © 2023 · The College Investor · Privacy Policy ·Terms of Service · DO NOT Sell My Personal Information

wpDiscuz