The Graduate’s Guide to Open Enrollment

For many employees, November and December is Open Enrollment, which means that it is the only time of the year that an employee can elect to enroll, modify, or cancel their benefits. This is a challenging time because you have to make a lot of decisions that are guaranteed to impact you for at least one year, and could impact you for the rest of your life should something happen.

The biggest decision you will most likely face is what type of health insurance coverage is best for you. Also, you could be deciding whether you and your spouse should double-cover each other. You may also have the options to enroll in short term or long term disability, dental insurance, vision coverage, different types of flexible spending account, legal, and many other types of options. To top it all off, most companies give you one week to enroll, and only get you the coverage information about a week before that!

Also, it is important to note that some employers only offer some options to those who elect it the first time. For example, you may only be offered supplemental life insurance and long term disability insurance the first time you are eligible. If you do not elect to have it, you may not be able to enroll again unless you have a “status change” such as marriage, baby, etc.

Well, here is a guide that will hopefully help you navigate through these difficult decisions.

Health Insurance Types

There are five main types of health insurance:

HMO – Health Maintenance Organization (i.e. Kaiser Permanente)
POS – Point of Service
PPO – Preferred Provider Organization
Indemnity – A health plan with no preferred network
HSA – Health Savings Account

All plans have certain aspects in common:

Deductible – This is the amount that must be paid before the insurance company pays. Some plans waive the deductible for wellness visits, flu shots, etc.

Coinsurance - After the deductible has been met, you enter into coinsurance. This is how the bill is split between you and the insurance company. A common split is 80/20, where you pay 20% of the bill, and the insurance company covers the remaining 80%. Many HMOs do not do coinsurance, you only pay your deductible. Coinsurance is very common with dental insurance.

Network – A group of providers, hospitals, etc. that you must use to get the best rate.

Now that you understand the basics, here is how each type of insurance breaks down:

HMO: An HMO usually utilizes a co-pay for all services (a deductible). This co-pay covers all services rendered during the visit. So, if you go for a physical, this will usually cover the labs, the doctor visit, etc. If there is coinsurance required, it is usually for hospital stays or advanced medical care. HMOs usually fully cover all basic services with the co-pay.

Pros – HMOs offer great basic coverage with less out of pocket costs during the year.

Cons – Less choices in hospitals and physicians, as everything must be in-network.

POS: A POS plan is an HMO plan that also includes an indemnity plan that allows you to go out of network if you choose.

PPO: A PPO plan almost always has a deductible and coinsurance. If you stay within the network for basic services (like a physical), there are also co-pays, but not a deductible or coinsurance. With PPOs, however, co-pays are usually NOT all-inclusive. It might cover seeing the doctor, but might not cover the lab tests. With a PPO, there is an indemnity plan that does allow you to see any doctor you wish, but the costs will be higher.

Pros – PPOs provide a huge amount of choice when it comes to doctors and hospitals

Cons – Coverage is not as comprehensive as an HMO, and the out-of-pocket costs are usually higher

Indemnity: This is the most basic type of health insurance, and it is what most young adults get to get by once coverage lapses from school/parents until they get coverage through their employer. It is also sometimes known as catastrophic coverage. It includes a high deductible (usually $500+), and some type of coinsurance to a point (typically $5,000 to $10,000), at which point the insurance covers the rest. This plan is designed as a last resort, as you would not go get a physical for a $500 deductible. Every PPO and POS plan includes this.

Pros- Coverage remains the same for any doctor or hospital seen. Ideal for last resort coverage to get buy until a full health insurance plan is available.

Cons – The cost is extremely high should a doctor be needed.

HSA: An HSA is essentially two different things: a tax deferred medical savings account and an indemnity-like health plan. First, you contribute pre-tax dollars to a medical savings account. If this money is used for medical costs, the money is never taxed. If you do not use this money, it becomes like an IRA, and at age 65, you can withdraw the funds without penalty. As for the health plan aspect, it is like an indemnity plan in that it has a high-deductible, but a low premium. There are usually no networks. This plan is ideal for healthy individuals looking for catastrophic coverage who want to save on their medical costs up front.

Pros – Low up-front costs, coverage remains the same for all doctors, pre-tax dollars are used.

Cons – If a doctor or hospital stay is needed, the out-of-pocket costs can rise rapidly

For the recent graduate, if you are healthy, I recommend either an HMO or HSA. If you are not employed, get an indemnity plan as quickly as possible. Here is a good resource to look at coverage available to you: Compare Affordable Health Insurance Instantly.

Double Coverage: If you are married, and both you and your spouse have insurance, you can each get family coverage and cover each other. Depending on the plan, this will usually eliminate your co-pays and deductibles, and significantly increases the amount that the insurance company will pay in coinsurance.

Disability Insurance

Many companies offer some type of disability insurance. Some automatically offer short term, but many require you to enroll in it. Both short term and long term disability insurance are smart investments because their premium costs are so low, and they can literally save your financial life should you become disabled. Furthermore, the Department of Labor estimates that nearly 1 in 5 working adults will become injured on the job requiring some type of leave.

Short Term Disability: This provides a percentage of your salary should injury or illness prevent you from working. Payments generally kick in once you exhaust all employer benefits (such as sick leave). Payments usually average around 40-60% of your salary. The duration is variable, but 6 months is fairly common.

Long Term Disability: This provides a percentage of your salary should you become permanently disabled and unable to earn a wage. These policies usually pick-up where the short-term policies end. Some last for 5-10 years, but you want to make sure that yours lasts until you are 65.

Once again, these policies are great buys! You should always enroll, as they can save you from a world of financial pain!

Dental Coverage

Dental coverage is another one of the best company provided insurance policies available. It is usually extremely cheap, and it keeps your mouth in working order. Dental insurance usually involves a deductible and coinsurance setup (which is usually 80/20). Dental coverage can also be double-covered with a spouse, so you can sometimes get out of the deductible.

Most dental coverage allows you to get your teeth cleaned twice a year, and x-rays once a year. This will keep you cavity free, and it is well worth the price.

Most dental plans will only cost you about $200 a YEAR!

Vision Coverage

Vision coverage is usually supplemental to your traditional health plan choices. If you need glasses or contacts, it is highly recommended that you get vision coverage. It is like dental coverage in that it is usually very cheap. If you get one prescription a year, you usually come out ahead by having vision coverage.

If you have great eyes, congratulations, you can skip this one.

Flexible Spending Accounts

A fairly new option available to employees is the flexible spending account. There are flexible spending accounts for healthcare, childcare, transportation, and many others. The benefit of these accounts is that you contribute a pre-set amount of pre-tax dollars a year, and you can use it for the designated reason (i.e. healthcare costs, childcare costs, etc.).

All types of flexible spending accounts have these characteristics:

Pre-Funding: You have to designate the amount you want to contribute to your FSA during your enrollment period, and you pay into it per paycheck. The great thing is that on day 1 of the plan year, you get to have access to the full amount you designated, even though you haven’t paid that amount yet. So, you get a tax-free loan on money. The second great thing is that if you leave the company, you don’t continue to pay in. So, if you spend all your FSA money, the company gave you a small advance as they have to pick-up the tab.

Use-it-or-lose-it: The biggest drawback of these plans is that you have to use the full amount during the plan year, or you lose it. This is especially difficult since you have to pre-fund. For FSAs for Healthcare, many individuals would simply purchase OTC medication to get their funds out their accounts. However, effective January 1, 2011, you can no longer purchase over-the-counter medication using an FSA unless you get a prescription for it from your doctor.

FSAs are a great tax-savings tool if they are used correctly. I use one every year, but I only contribute a few hundred dollars into it to make sure that I don’t lose it. I find that once you get a couple of years of medical services under your belt, you can use that to estimate how much you will spend on health care. If you use a product like Mint, you can keep track of your health care costs automatically.

Other Coverage

Many companies offer other coverages, such as group legal or fitness programs. These can be good deals, but it is important to shop around. You may realize that there are a lot of limitations to the policies and plans that your employer is offering.

With all coverage options, be sure to thoroughly read through any materials provided. Also, many employers offer calculators to check the different costs of each plan so that you can see what you will really pay.

I hope this article helps you make an informed decision. Please share any thoughts or comments you may have!