• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The College Investor

Student Loans, Investing, Building Wealth

  • About
  • Podcasts
  • Research
  • Contact
  • Save For College
      • How To Start

      • How To Save For College
      • How To Pay For College
      • What Is the Average Cost of College?
      • What Is A 529 Plan and Where to Open One in Your State
      • How Much Should You Have In A 529 Plan By Age
      • How To Use A 529 Plan For Private Elementary And High School
      • What Are Qualified Expenses For A 529 Plan (And What Doesn’t Count)?
      • The Best Brokers To Open A 529 Plan
      • Tools + Accounts

      • 529 Plans: The Ultimate College Savings Plan
      • 529 Plan Contribution Limits
      • Prepaid Tuition Plans | What To Know
      • Understanding And Using 529A ABLE Accounts
      • Using A Roth IRA To Save And Pay For College
      • FAFSA Deadlines for Financial Aid
      • CollegeBacker Review
      • Upromise Review
      • UNest Review
      • Other Options

      • Student Loan And Financial Aid Programs By State
      • The Guide To Military And VA Education Benefits
      • How To Fill Out The FAFSA
      • How To Find College Scholarships
      • The Best College Scholarship Search Websites
      • How To Find Grants To Pay For College
      • Pell Grants: What They Are And How To Qualify
      • Understanding Federal Work-Study
      • How To Use A 529 Plan If Your Child Doesn’t Go To College
  • Student Loans
      • Borrowing

        • How Student Loans Work
        • How To Apply For A Student Loan
        • Best Student Loans And Rates In September 2023
        • 10 Best Private Student Loans Of September 2023
        • Best Student Loans To Pay For Graduate School
        • Best Student Loans For Medical School
        • Parent Loans To Pay For College
        • No-Cosigner Student Loan Options
        • Guide To Income Sharing Agreements (ISAs)
        • Best International Student Loans
      • Get Out Of Debt

        • Best Student Loan Refinance Companies In September 2023
        • Best Student Loan Repayment Plans
        • Best Student Loan Refinancing Bonuses And Promotional Offers Of September 2023
        • Student Loan Forgiveness Programs (The Complete List)
        • The Full List Of Student Loan Forgiveness Programs By State
        • Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF)
        • Top Student Loan Scams
        • Average Student Loan Monthly Payment
        • Average Student Loan Debt By Year
      • Reviews

        • Credible Review
        • Splash Review
        • Ascent Review
        • Citizens Bank Review
        • Earnest Review
        • ELFI Review
        • Laurel Road Review
        • LendKey Review
        • SoFi Review
        • Sallie Mae Review
  • Investing
      • How To Start

        • How To Start Investing in High School
        • How To Start Investing In College
        • How To Start Investing In Your Twenties For 22 – 29 Year Olds
        • How To Start Investing In Your 30s For 30 – 39 Year Olds
        • How To Start Investing With $100 Or Less
        • How To Give Kids The Gift Of Stock
        • What Is Dividend Growth Investing
        • IRA Rollover Chart
      • Tools + Accounts

        • Best Online Stock Brokers
        • The Best Traditional And Roth IRA Accounts
        • The Best Robo-Advisors
        • The Best Investing Apps
        • The Best Places to Trade Options
        • The Best Places To Open A Health Savings Account
        • The Best Solo 401k Providers
        • The Best Self-Directed IRA Providers Of 2023
        • Best Cryptocurrency Exchanges
      • Reviews

        • Vanguard Review
        • Fidelity Review 2023
        • M1 Finance Review
        • TD Ameritrade Review 2023
        • Charles Schwab Review
        • Robinhood Review
        • Webull Review
        • Betterment Review 2023
        • Wealthfront Review
  • Earn More Money
      • Extra Income

        • 20 Best Side Hustles You Can Start Earning With In 2023
        • 54 Side Hustle Ideas To Make Money Fast In 2023
        • 100 Ways To Make Money In College In 2023
        • How To Make Money From Home: 80 Irresistible Ideas
        • How To Make Money In One Hour: 5 Quick Ideas You Can Try Now
        • 10 Interesting Ways You Can Make Money Driving
        • High-Paying Side Gigs That Earn $1,000 or More Per Month
        • The 10 Best Money-Making Apps
        • Best Paid Survey Site List: Earn Money For Giving Your Opinion Online
        • 10 Crazy Ways To Make $10,000 You’ve Never Heard Of
      • Build Wealth

        • 40 Passive Income Ideas For 2023 To Build Real Wealth
        • 3 Ways To Make $50,000 Per Year Without Working With Passive Income
        • How To Become A Real Estate Investor With Just $500
        • 15 Best Online Business Ideas
        • Residual Income: 7 Super Smart Ways to Build It
        • The Most Common Multiple Income Streams
        • How To Become A Real Estate Mogul With Only $10,000
      • Reviews

        • Fundrise Review
        • RealtyMogul Review
        • FarmTogether Review
        • AcreTrader Review
        • Swagbucks Review
        • Survey Junkie Review
        • TopCashback Review
        • DoorDash Review
  • Personal Finance
      • Banking

        • Best High Yield Savings Accounts Of September 2023
        • 10 Best Money Market Accounts Of September 2023
        • 10 Best Free Checking Accounts In September 2023
        • Best Bank CD Rates
        • 10 Best Business Checking Accounts In September 2023
        • Best Online Banks Of September 2023
        • Best Credit Unions Nationwide Of September 2023
        • Best College Student Checking Accounts Of September 2023
      • Insurance

        • Best Life Insurance Companies
        • Renters Insurance
        • Car Insurance
        • Pet Insurance
        • Umbrella Insurance
        • Disability Insurance
        • Tuition Insurance
        • Travel Insurance
      • Credit Tools

        • Best Budgeting Apps
        • Cash Advance Apps
        • How To Get A Free Credit Score Report
        • Best Credit Monitoring Services For 2023
        • Debt Settlement: Inside The Secret World
        • Credit Repair Explained: Should You Pay For Help?
        • Best Personal Loan Companies And Lenders
        • Online Loan Companies To Borrow From Home
      • Tax

        • Best Tax Software
        • Free Tax Software
        • IRS Tax Refund Calendar
        • Common IRS Questions and Errors
        • Federal Tax Brackets
        • Capital Gains Tax Brackets
        • 401k Contribution Limits
        • IRA Contribution Limits
        • HSA Contribution Limits
  • Awards
  • Search
Home / Investing / Real Estate / How To Appeal An Appraisal On Your Home (My Experience)

How To Appeal An Appraisal On Your Home (My Experience)

Updated: June 21, 2023 By Robert Farrington

1Share
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Email
  • Print

At The College Investor, we want to help you navigate your finances. To do this, many or all of the products featured here may be from our partners. This doesn’t influence our evaluations or reviews. Our opinions are our own. Any investing information provided on this page is for educational purposes only. The College Investor does not offer investment advisor or brokerage services, nor does it recommend buying or selling particular stocks, securities, or other investments. Learn more here.Advertiser Disclosure

There are thousands of financial products and services out there, and we believe in helping you understand which is best for you, how it works, and will it actually help you achieve your financial goals. We're proud of our content and guidance, and the information we provide is objective, independent, and free.

But we do have to make money to pay our team and keep this website running! Our partners compensate us. TheCollegeInvestor.com has an advertising relationship with some or all of the offers included on this page, which may impact how, where, and in what order products and services may appear. The College Investor does not include all companies or offers available in the marketplace. And our partners can never pay us to guarantee favorable reviews (or even pay for a review of their product to begin with).

For more information and a complete list of our advertising partners, please check out our full Advertising Disclosure. TheCollegeInvestor.com strives to keep its information accurate and up to date. The information in our reviews could be different from what you find when visiting a financial institution, service provider or a specific product's website. All products and services are presented without warranty.

Appeal Home Appraisal

If you've been through the home purchasing and lending process before, you know it is extremely tedious. You have to fill out long applications, get a bunch of paper work in order, and so on. In general, it is a lot of "hurry up, then wait". But the biggest factor most people are waiting on is the home appraisal.

Well, last week, after a period of waiting, we got the appraisal back on the house we were looking to buy, and it ended up coming in a full $70,000 below our offer price, and well below fair market value to similar properties inside the same development. SO IRRITATING!

How could the appraiser think the value was so low? As a buyer, you'd think that would be a good thing (a lower price, right?), but in reality, this seriously jeopardized our deal. If we couldn't get a loan, the seller would have moved on, and sold the house at or near or offer price. We weren't overpaying for the house... something was just wrong.

Table of Contents
The Appraiser Botched The Report
My Options To Appeal the Appraisal
Starting With My Lender
A New Lender, A New Appraisal
It's Not Over - I'm Still Appealing My Home Appraisal
Final Thoughts On The Process

The Appraiser Botched The Report

After reviewing the home appraisal, it became very clear what happened: the appraiser who did my appraisal botched the report. I can never say for sure if it was "pencil whipped" or he just made a lot of mistakes, but the bottom line is that there were 8 different technical and factual errors that contributed to this extremely low property valuation. To make me even more frustrated, the appraiser only got his appraiser license 2 weeks prior to doing my house (in our state, appraisers have to be licensed and you can see a proof of their license in the report)!

Here are several factual things he missed that I found when looking over the report in detail:

  • He said he reviewed the sales contract (according to a box he checked on the report), but didn't include any of the seller concessions or the appliances included in the sale.
  • He had several discrepancies in the description of the home, including the foundation and exterior and interior descriptions
  • The first comparable sale he used was a foreclosure from last year, which is currently a pending sale as of the appraisal date. Instead of listing it as an active listing for the current price of $550,000, he listed it as a closed sale for the foreclosure price of $338,000. That is a huge difference and is probably what directly impacted the value of my home. You can obviously see it was a flip, and the appraiser totally failed to note that.
  • Comparable sale #5 was a similar issue. It is a current foreclosure listed for $390,000, but he listed the condition as good and needing no repair. However, if you look at the MLS listing, it is obviously in need of over $100,000 in repairs to bring it up to current market value.

Basically, all of these issues combined just hammered the home's value. The other 4 comparable sales all support the price I offered, but these two mentioned completely tank the market value.

My Options To Appeal the Appraisal

Now this is where it gets pretty irritating. Luckily, I'm doing a conventional mortgage, so I have the opportunity to appeal the appraiser. However, if I had gone with an FHA mortgage, you don't get that option. Even then, the opportunity to appeal varies from lender to lender.

For my situation, I have to write a letter to my lender detailing exactly what was wrong with the appraisal and how I believe it contributed to an incorrect home value. Then, only if the lender agrees and the appraiser agrees, does the appraisal actually get re-done.

If both parties don't agree, my only other option is to get another lender and start the process all over. Let's just say that sounds a whole lot easier than it actually was.

So here is what I did to get my home appraisal fixed.

Starting With My Lender

My lender had very strict rules it follows for appraisals. Part of their bank's policy is to only allow one appraisal. The only option if the buyer feels that it is wrong is to appeal it with the appraiser. So I sent in this very detailed letter highlighting the 8 different material problems with the appraisal - no disputes on comparable sales used, just pure factual errors.

What I got back was startling. The appraiser wrote a reply back that said just this: "In the opinion of the appraiser, the report remains valid as is and no corrections/adjustments are necessary". They didn't even state why, and the appraisal management company agreed.

As a result, my lender refused to order a new appraisal or do anything else with the price of the home.

A New Lender, A New Appraisal

Luckily, I had a second lender which was competing for my business (I always shop around for a home loan). I immediately called her, and she was able to get an appraisal ordered within 5 days of the appeal letter being denied. This lender did an amazing job getting all the paperwork and appraisal completed in record time.

The appraisal came back at my first offer price, which was a whopping $70,000 higher than the botched appraisal (talk about a discrepancy). Furthermore, this new lender was able to get me a better rate since we waited and rates had gone down in the interim. Finally, she was able to close on time - she closed the loan from start to finish in about 15 days!

We finally got our new home!

It's Not Over - I'm Still Appealing My Home Appraisal

However, I couldn't let the bullshit from the first lender and their appraisal stand. After the new appraisal came back, I called the first lender and respectfully asked for a refund of the appraisal fee I paid, since it was incorrect (that's $450). I then sent them a copy of the new appraisal (which actually used 4 of the 6 comparable sales from the original), and highlighted all the factual errors in their appraisal.

The poor loan officer couldn't do that, but she sent it to her supervisor. The supervisor initially refused to offer me a refund, but suggested that if I could get the State Board of Appraisers to agree that the appraisal was faulty, they would agree to refund my money. For a $450 refund, I thought "what did I have to lose?".

I went to the state's website and filled out a complaint form, and provided all the information.  I included:

  • The faulty appraisal
  • The appeal letter
  • The MLS of the comps
  • The appraiser's response
  • A copy of the new appraisal

A day after closing my property (2 weeks after the whole debacle occurred), I heard back from the State Board, who agreed that the appraisal was, in fact, faulty, and that they are recommending the appraiser take additional continuing education classes as punishment.

I sent this letter to my lender, who agreed to refund my money!  Victory!

Final Thoughts On The Process

It's terrible that a single individual can have such a derailing effect on buying a home. It's also annoying that banks place so much faith in a single individual's thoughts on what a home is worth, without reading the report themselves to see if it's even accurate. They are just looking at the number, no matter what.

I also do feel bad for the appraisers. In reading about their industry, they get little pay, have to drive all over, fill out multiple reports per day - it's easy to see how things can be quickly done and mistakes can be made.

The bottom line is that you don't have to let a bad appraisal derail your process.

Robert Farrington
Robert Farrington

Robert Farrington is America’s Millennial Money Expert® and America’s Student Loan Debt Expert™, and the founder of The College Investor, a personal finance site dedicated to helping millennials escape student loan debt to start investing and building wealth for the future. You can learn more about him on the About Page or on his personal site RobertFarrington.com.

He regularly writes about investing, student loan debt, and general personal finance topics geared toward anyone wanting to earn more, get out of debt, and start building wealth for the future.

He has been quoted in major publications, including the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, ABC, NBC, Today, and more. He is also a regular contributor to Forbes.

Appeal Home Appraisal
Editorial Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here are author’s alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, airlines or hotel chain, or other advertiser and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.
Comment Policy: We invite readers to respond with questions or comments. Comments may be held for moderation and are subject to approval. Comments are solely the opinions of their authors'. The responses in the comments below are not provided or commissioned by any advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any company. It is not anyone's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.
Subscribe
Connect with
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
Notify of

I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Primary Sidebar

Robert Farrington will teach you how to get out of student loan debt and how to start investing.

Hi! My Name is

America's Millennial Money Expert

Welcome to The College Investor. We're here to help you escape student loan debt so you can start investing and building wealth for the future

Our expert guides, reviews, and more are designed to help you achieve your financial goals.

Want to learn more? See what's in my wallet.

As Featured In

Social Media

Popular Posts

Best Side Hustles

20 Best Side Hustles You Can Start Earning With In 2023

Side Hustle Ideas

54 Side Hustle Ideas To Make Money Fast In 2023

wait to repay your student loans

For-Profit College Student Loan Forgiveness List

Passive Income Ideas

40 Passive Income Ideas For 2023 To Build Real Wealth

Student Loan Forgiveness Programs

Student Loan Forgiveness Programs (The Complete List)

Most Expensive Colleges

20 Most Expensive Colleges In 2023

529 Plan By Age

How Much Should You Have In A 529 Plan By Age

Net Worth of Millennials

Average Net Worth Of Millennials By Age

Qualified 529 plan Expenses

What Are Qualified Expenses For A 529 Plan (And What Doesn’t Count)?

Ultimate Guides

Student Loan Forgiveness Programs By State

The Full List Of Student Loan Forgiveness Programs By State

529 Plan Guide

529 Plans: The Ultimate Guide To College Savings Plans

Student Loans and Financial Aid By State

Student Loan And Financial Aid Programs By State

Student Loan Advice

The Definitive Guide To Student Loan Debt

newretirement

How to Start Saving Now: The College Graduate’s Guide to Saving for Retirement

Latest Research

undermatching at selective colleges

Undermatching: Why Do Smart Low-Income Students Not Enroll In Selective Colleges?

Student Loan Borrowers Are Not Ready To Resume Payments

Survey: 55% Of Student Loan Borrowers Don’t Feel Ready To Resume Payments

How much to file taxes

Tax Survey: How Much People Paid To File And The No.1 Tax Software They Used

Inflation survey

Survey Shows 86% Stressed Over Money & Inflation (Side-Hustles To The Rescue!

students choose to work survey

Should I Work While In College? 75% Of Students Say “Yes”

Footer

Who We Are

The College Investor is an independent, advertising-supported financial media publisher, focusing on news, product reviews, and comparisons.

Connect

  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Press & Media

About

  • About
  • Our Team
  • Podcast
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • How We Make Money
  • Archives

Social

Copyright © 2023 · The College Investor · Privacy Policy ·Terms of Service · DO NOT Sell My Personal Information

wpDiscuz